Tuesday, 4 September 2012

A Red Perspective - Match Report: Barnsley 1-0 Bristol City

A Red Perspective

First Half:


Jacob Mellis was the difference between these two sides in a game that should have been more comfortable than it was for the home team. The ex-Chelsea man headed a home a superb cross from Martin Cranie in the 50th minute which kept up Barnsley's 100% home record, but that wasn't the main talking point; a two-footed lunge from Bobby Hassell on Bristol's Jon Stead reduced the home side to ten men, but that didn't matter in the end as a resilient performance in the second half gave the points to Barnsley.

On the back of conceding eight goals in two league games, Barnsley fought through late forward surges from a determined Bristol side who were in contrasting form going into this game, having scored eight in their previous two league outings.

Barnsley started the game very nervously and it was evident for everyone to see - both Ben Alnwick and Chris Dagnall dawdling on the ball resulting in losses of possession.

Bristol had the better of the opening five minutes, carving out several chances but never really tested Alnwick, looking to redeem himself from his red card on his debut.

More uncertainty about the new goalkeeper on six minutes as his poor clearance led to another Bristol chance but this time the Barnsley defence were quick to close down, causing Albert Adomah to aimlessly hoof the ball over the top in hope, but to no avail.

The home side were - against Keith Hill's style of play - resorting to the long ball up to 6' 2" marksman Craig Davies to try and create some chances to break the deadlock but there were no signs of Bristol's defence letting anything through anytime soon.

Another error in Barnsley's back line seven minutes in - this time from stand-in captain Scott Wiseman - allowed Stead to turn and unleash a tame curling effort but his deflected shot rolled harmlessly into the grateful arms of Alnwick.

Bristol continued to attack and were dominating the game until Tomasz Cywka dribbled his way down the centre of the pitch before sending the ball out to his left to find Davies in acres of space, and the Welshman let fly with a bending effort that cannoned back off of Thomas Heaton's left-hand post to Mellis whose scuffed attempt ricocheted wide for Barnsley's first corner of the game.

The tide of the game was beginning to turn in Barnsley's favour, and they started to pile on the pressure with two threatening corners being met by Stephen Foster's headers but the away defence dealt with them comfortably.

Pinball in the Reds penalty area on 13 minutes created a half-chance for Bristol, but the ball wouldn't drop for Martyn Woolford, as Alnwick got down well to smother it and avert any danger.

Any attacks down the left wing for Bristol were always cut out by the tremendous Cranie on his home debut - a solid performance from the Coventry old boy went down brilliantly with the vocally strong crowd on Saturday.

A quarter of an hour into the match and appeals from Barnsley fans for a penalty for handball went unheard when Davies' strike appeared to have hit Bristol City defender Louis Carey on his lower arm.

Having come closest to opening the scoring, Barnsley pushed on to try and find this important first goal and as hard as they tried, they didn't succeed. They again came close just before the 2o minute mark when Mellis' lofted ball into the box was cleared out to Hassell who beat two players, passed to Dagnall on the right-hand side of the area, and the 26 year old's snapshot was well saved by Heaton after a neat turn on the edge of the box.

The resulting corner caused havoc in the Bristol penalty area and some slack movement from Adomah allowed Cranie to win possession and play a neat little ball out to Mellis who blazed his effort way over the bar. The signs were positive and Barnsley were getting closer.

Midway through the first half and the Reds were firmly on top of this encounter now, breezing forward with ease and troubling Bristol's defence with any chance they got - Cywka brilliantly working his way away from Woolford before chipping a lovely ball to the far post but unfortunately no one was there to head home this crisp cross and the ball was nodded away by Carey.

Sloppy play from Mark Wilson a minute later gifted the ball to Davies and he drilled a 25 yard shot low and hard but it was straight down the centre of the goal and into the thankful arms of Heaton.

Barnsley came their closest yet to getting on the score sheet when Cywka found space on the edge of the area and dinked a lovely ball on to the head of Davies and his downwards header was palmed away superbly by Heaton and the ball was then deterred from all danger as Adomah hacked the ball high upfield.

A nifty run from Dagnall just before the half hour point allowed him to play in a low ball but his cross bounced off the leg of Cywka - nothing the Pole could do about that.

Barnsley were fully into their stride now and were creating chances galore, Cywka and Mellis being at the forefront of every Reds attack and some great vision from both played in Davies on two occasions but the striker failed to conjure up a goal. Mellis was then played through by a terrific ball from Stephen Dawson but he fired his attempt inches wide of Heaton's left post.

The away side had time to regroup in the five minutes that followed and looked to be holding off Barnsley's forceful attacks well until Dagnall squirmed into the box and laid the ball off to Davies whose quick-fire shot sparked half-hearted appeals for a penalty for handball from the Barnsley faithful, but the referee wasn't having any of it.

Some excellent passing and movement from the whole midfield line and full backs five minutes before the interval allowed the Reds to work their way into space and Mellis further bettered his already fantastic performance by sliding the ball into Dawson who flicked it up and struck his left-footed volley into the ground. The ball was destined for the bottom corner but Heaton got down well to grasp it.

Barnsley came even closer to breaking through on the stroke of half time - Cywka playing a sweet ball through the middle for Dagnall to run on to but the striker was just beaten to the ball by Heaton who collected it whilst receiving a blow to the head due to Dagnall's momentum causing him to collide with the Bristol number one.



Second Half:


The second period kicked off and Bristol City brought on Marvin Elliott for the ineffective Adomah to keep up with Barnsley's packed midfield - the winger struggling to cope in his unnatural position of central midfield.

Five minutes into the second half and the Reds got that breakthrough they so thoroughly deserved - Mellis planting his header on to the underside of the crossbar and in after a magnificent cross from Cranie.

Things took a turn for the worst only a minute after the goal as Hassell's rash foul was deemed to be worthy of a red card by referee Steve Rushton. The full back went in high on Bristol striker Stead and could have no complaints after being given his marching orders.

That sending off opened up a portal for Bristol to get back into the game but Barnsley were not to be pushed over and held a tight defensive line as Bristol struggled to show any real penetration.

Bristol came their closest yet when pinball madness in the penalty area resulted in the ball bouncing to Sam Baldock nine yards out, but the £1m+ man could only find Alnwick's gloves when under intense pressure from the home defenders.

This chance sparked a flurry of attacks from the away side but Barnsley were holding their own with only ten men - Cole Skuse the first to try his luck but his effort from distance was well blocked by Wiseman.

With an hour of the match surpassed Barnsley brought on teenage prodigy John Stones for goal scoring hero Mellis, and also introduced Marlon Harewood who replaced the impressive Davies - This made something click and the Reds were suddenly in the ascendency again.

Despite Barnsley's dominance so far, some good link up play from Stead and Woolford - combined with poor keeping from Alnwick - allowed the Bristol winger to nip in behind the 'keeper and with only Stones on the line, Woolford's header brought an outstanding block from the 18 year old local lad - however, the ex-Scunthorpe maestro really should have equalised.

Bristol brought on Ryan Taylor on 67 minutes in place of new-boy Baldock to try and find a goal to level the scores.

The sending off of Hassell meant Barnsley had to resort to a deep defensive line and the Robins were finding it difficult to pierce through this stubborn back four, having to alternate to long shots instead of trying to writhe and wriggle their way through.

Another half-chance for the visitors with 20 minutes remaining on the clock - this time a whipped cross over to the back post meant substitute Elliott was always stretching to get a good connection and his slight touch sent the ball behind for a goal kick - relief for Barnsley.

Bristol brought on more attacking strength on 73 minutes when Steven Davies - recently signed from Derby - replaced midfielder Stephen Pearson, and Davies was involved in the action straight away. Greg Cunningham played a 40 yard pass right on to the penalty spot and as Alnwick came out, flapped, and completely missed the ball, Davies only managed to steer his header wide when he should have done better.

The instrumental Cywka was trying his luck again with 77 minutes gone as he dispossessed Davies, ran at the visiting defenders and fired wide from 25 yards when he had options either side in Harewood and Dagnall.

The Reds were persistent and kept darting forward whenever possible - Dagnall and Cywka doing extremely well on several instances and showing true grit, determination, and that never say die attitude.

Bristol came closer yet - Davies again heading an inch wide of Alnwick's right-hand side post when he should have done better, and despite having the man advantage, the away side were on the back foot for most of the remaining ten minutes after Harewood and Dawson broke through the Bristol back line with some energetic bursts of football.

Barnsley very nearly doubled their lead with the clock ticking over into injury time as Stones steamed forward and curled a lovely ball around the away team's centre back that landed at Harewood's feet but the striker just couldn't get any power behind the shot and the covering defender got back to clear the ball off of the line and into Heaton's appreciative arms.

Bristol struck the bar in the 91st minute through Davies as his free kick thundered past a stranded Alnwick in goal - an equaliser would have been harsh on Barnsley who had been the better side for long periods of the game and had shown fantastic resilience after going a man down.

Barnsley did everything they could to keep the ball in the corner to run down the timer and intelligent play from the remarkable Harewood allowed him to convince the away defenders he was going to the corner before quickly shifting his path inwards and bearing down on goal, and from a tight angle he couldn't beat Heaton in the City net.

Full time at Oakwell and the final score finished Barnsley 1-0 Bristol City.



Jacob Mellis heading home the winner.



Barnsley Ratings:

Starting XI:

Ben Alnwick - 6 - Poor distribution from the keeper and tended to flap at everything. One decent save in a below par performance.

Martin Cranie - 9 - A phenomenal performance from the new boy. He adapted extremely well in various positions and supplied a marvellous cross for the winner.

Scott Wiseman - 8 - Looks to be finding his feet now he's being played at central defence, and despite a shaky start, looked commanding at the back and made some crucial blocks.

Stephen Foster - 7 - Assured as always and had a couple of chances in the first half. He seems to be past his best Oakwell days now but is still always a reliable player at the back.

Scott Golbourne - 7 - Great going forward and has a lot of flair for a defender but does have a tendency to get caught out and is more than often having to track back.

Bobby Hassell - 7 - Decent up until the sending off, which was unlikely for a man of his experience. Was the heart of a few attacks in the first half too.

Stephen Dawson - 8 - Seemed to be carrying the team when they needed it after the dismissal. Could be an ideal captain as his communication is second to none.

Tomasz Cywka - 9 - Man of the match and deservedly so. A magnificent performance and some amazing footwork that could only have been topped off by a goal.

Jacob Mellis - 9 - Played his role brilliantly until he was subbed off. Took his goal well and created a fair few chances and could very well turn out to be better than the old Jacob, we'll see.

Chris Dagnall - 9 - After coming under recent criticism, he may well have silenced doubters with an amazing performance that warranted a goal. Sublime work rate and never gives up.

Craig Davies - 8 - Fantastic hold up play from him and was very unlucky not to grab a goal after he hit the post. This could be a great season for him.


Subs:


John Stones - 8 - Outstanding. That clearance may well have won the points for Barnsley and he never stopped going until the final whistle. A few misplaced passes but that'll go with experience.

Marlon Harewood - 8 - Came on to do a job and did that job, and did it very well. His hold up play mirrored Davies' and his strength was vital when it came to keeping the ball in the corner.

Monday, 3 September 2012

Summer Transfer Window: Wheelings And Dealings

Barnsley fans tend to dread the time when the transfer window comes around, and with good reason to. It is normally the case that the best players at Oakwell are destined to move on, be it an uphill or downhill move, and this summer has so far proven to be no different with creative captain Jacob Butterfield packing his bags for a move to the bright lights of the Premier League with Norwich City. However it's not just the outgoings that are the vitriolic reminders of why Barnsley fans hate this time in the calendar year... Many incomings have created a sense of worry and false panic, and this was shown through Keith Hill's signings in his first year at Oakwell - he brought in League One players who against the odds, performed at consistently higher standards than most of our so called 'Championship-proven' players. So here starts my quick look over our new recruits so far...


Mido 


Of course, there's no better place to start than with the Egyptian ace that is Mido, the man who astonished a whole nation when he penned a one-year deal at Oakwell. Formerly of Ajax, Marseille, Tottenham and Middlesbrough, Mido was brought in by Keith Hill seemingly to replace the void left by hold-up man Andy Gray, and on my first and as of yet only viewing of him, away at Alfreton, he did just that despite not being heavily involved in proceedings. He did show Dagnall-esque qualities though as he blazed over the bar from six yards out. Since his Premier League days he's flown back to his native Egypt and due to the financial struggles in his homeland's top division he offered to play for a mere £1,000 a week. In his two year hiatus away from England he's piled on the pounds and won't be fully fit until September at the earliest according to Hill. Despite the increase in his weight that will undoubtedly have affected his abilities, fans can take solace in the fact that he will be able to bring a wealth of experience from his time across Europe with him to Barnsley to benefit others and may be able to showcase skills he learnt from past strike partners such as Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Didier Drogba.

I and many other fans will be hoping this tremendous coup will prove to be another Ricardo Vaz Te story, and if Hill can nurture Mido like he did with the Portuguese superstar then he'll be sure to make opposition defenders quake in their boots. However, getting Mido up to that standard will prove to be a much sterner test and will really assess Hill's capabilities. Mido and Hill will know that with strong dedication and endeavour from the both of them could see the stocky striker rediscover his form from his early career days which saw him transfer between European giants.


Mido in action on his debut - he needs to shed the pounds.



Tomasz Cywka


Now I've been a fan of the tricky little Polish attacking midfielder for a couple of years now. The creative star will bring added flair to an already inventive side and his scintillating runs will entertain the adoring fans and attract the crowds. Derby fans don't understand why Nigel Clough released him from his contract, and on recent evidence their views can only be backed further. An impressive debut against Rochdale saw him grab two assists after coming on from the bench. A similar player to Jacob Mellis, the two could go hand in hand in the centre of the park.

Putting in a man of the match performance in the game vs Bristol, more appearances like that would surely propel Barnsley up the table. However, like Vaz Te, he is only on a year-long contract and it is essential that we tie the 24 year old down on a longer basis before he the curse hits Barnsley again and we lose another gem for next to nothing in January.


Cywka's talent will delight the crowds.



Kelvin Etuhu

Kelvin Etuhu was a player who Keith Hill has been fond of for a while now and after pursuing his signature last term, he finally got the young Nigerian to put pen to paper on a one-year deal at Oakwell. On the books of Manchester City as a youngster, he never showed the talent expected of him - appearing a disappointing ten times in five years - and was loaned out on various occasions to Football League clubs where fans around the country got glimpses of his unquestionable quality. Combining electric pace with his silky dribbling, he could be a deadly opponent for defenders in the forthcoming season and being able to operate anywhere across the forward line could pay its dividends for both the Yorkshire outfit and Etuhu himself. This isn't the first time Hill has worked with Etuhu - he was on loan at Rochdale in 2007 under Hill's reign which fits the 'Hill DNA' as some fans like to call it.

Brought in as the first signing in Hill's second season as a Championship level manager, he'll have a tough job working his way to being an fan favourite such as other past wingers Jamal Campbell-Ryce, and more noticeably, Adam Hammill. In March 2011 Etuhu was handed an eight month prison sentence following an attack the previous year, and most fans will more than likely be hoping the speedy Nigerian winger will be able to replicate this dynamic attitude and aggression on the pitch.


Etuhu has pace to burn.


Jacob Mellis 


Ex-Barnsley loanee Jacob Mellis was sacked by Chelsea in March this year following a training ground incident in which Mellis set off a smoke bomb, and after trial periods at QPR and Burnley, the creative Nottingham-born midfielder signed a two-year deal at Barnsley. Following on from this, police were called to his home in April after a fight broke out between him and his girlfriend. This signing triggered debate amongst fans as shortly after the episode that got him sacked, Keith Hill told the media he would not have someone who could disrupt the high-spirited morale around the dressing room in his team, yet went back on his word only three months later - which is not like Hill, given his stubborn nature.

Offering a range of qualities to the team, Mellis could be a real star for Barnsley this season and could outshine most other young prospects in the league. His perfectly executed passes can unlock defences with relative ease and he knows how to strike a ball as well as possessing decent pace, which for a central midfielder is vital - especially in a league which is as demanding as the Championship. Despite being touted as a new star, Mellis does reiterate the fact that he feels he is not a young hotshot anymore so this season is a chance to prove his worth to the manager, fans, and the footballing world.

The signing of Mellis is a signal of intent from manager Hill as he promised Championship quality players - and Reds fans know all about Mellis' eminence - after two goals and a handful of brilliant performances in early 2011. Mellis was signed ahead of other central midfielders Oliver Norwood and Lee Williamson, who now play for Huddersfield and Portsmouth respectively. Brought in to replace the old Jacob, the new Jacob brings with him the abilities of former captain Butterfield and is a similar sort of midfielder to the new Premier League player, with respect to his physical and mental attributes. All in all he is a very exciting addition to the squad and I for one look forward to seeing him play week in week out.


This is Mellis' second spell at Barnsley.



Toni Silva


In late July speculation circulated around Oakwell after it was revealed that a Liverpool player would be joining the revolution at Oakwell on a permanent deal. Names were thrown around by fans such as Conor Coady or Nathan Eccleston - the latter of whom spent time on loan at Rochdale, not under Keith Hill's time in charge I may add - but Keith loves Rochdale players both new and old, doesn't he? It was eventually announced that Portuguese winger Toni Silva was the man who was signing for the South Yorkshire outfit.

Now I can't say I've seen that much of Silva playing but from what I've heard from the Liverpool faithful, he's a great player who has lightning speed in abundance and is a fantastic dribbler who knows how to create chances. He did spend a period of last season on loan at Northampton Town, notching only one goal in 15 league appearances, and the reviews I've got from The Cobblers' fans vastly contrasting, with supporters saying that he's not good enough to cut it at this level. He'll have to prove those fans wrong by putting in some good shifts at Oakwell to get ahead of fellow wingers Jim O'Brien, Kelvin Etuhu and Matt Done.





A video of Silva's two goals on his Liverpool U18s debut.




Ben Alnwick


Brought in to cover for Luke Steele, journeyman Ben Alnwick hasn't had the best of starts to life at Oakwell after being offered a chance to resurrect his career by Keith Hill. Prudhoe-born Alnwick was highly touted to be the next great English 'keeper when he completed a £1.3m move to North London to don the white of Tottenham in 2007 as an inexperienced 20 year old. Seven loan spells in four years never allowed him to show his potential and as a result, was released in the summer of 2012.

When he first signed for Barnsley some fans went as far as to say in him and Luke Steele we had "the two best shot stoppers in the league" and I was quick to agree with that statement, until he made his debut... He has been nothing but average in his first few games and along with being given his marching orders on his first start, has made countless errors. Mixed with poor distribution and even poorer kicking, it would appear the standard of Alnwick's game is on par with that of mistake prone Vito Mannone - yes, that bad. However, the season is young and the now 25 year old has plenty of time to make amends for his meagre performances.


Alnwick needs to improve after his first few games.



Marlon Harewood


Marlon Harewood, like Jacob Mellis, is now in his second stint at Barnsley after a spell that gained him mixed reviews from Barnsley fans, and in my eyes, the four goals in ten games that the ex-West Ham, Aston Villa and Blackpool striker scored only resulted in him giving a good account of himself. Now back at the club after a period in China and then at Nottingham Forest, he's restarted his Barnsley career without putting a foot wrong. The big man looks like the ideal replacement for Andy Gray and has the perfect physical stature to hold the ball up as well as chip in with a few goals. The Hampstead-born forward also brings fantastic positional sense to the squad, and that could be the difference between winning or losing games. Amalgamated with Craig Davies, Harewood's strength and awareness could prove to be half of a fruitful partnership with the Welshman and I for one cannot wait to see how it pans out.

Harewood in action away at Wolves.



Martin Cranie

The eighth and final signing of the summer for Keith Hill. Martin Cranie provides extreme versatility which could cause problems aplenty for Hill regarding his selection choices. He can play anywhere across the back four as well as just in front of them in a defensive midfield role and that's a key element in any successful squad - being versatile. Another free transfer, Cranie's last club was newly relegated Coventry City, where he was highly rated amongst the Sky Blues fans, and his time at the Ricoh Arena also brought Cranie the most successful stage in his career so far.

Not the tallest of defenders at only six foot, a good leap gives him that extra inch in the air needed to beat his opponent to the ball which is pivotal. Assurance is guaranteed in abundance as Cranie is a no-nonsense, solid centre back who gets his job done efficiently. A very similar player to Jimmy McNulty in a certain sense - operating in different positions is a big part of his game, and he portrayed this magnificently in the recent win over Bristol City, in which he delivered a sublime cross to allow Jacob Mellis to head home the winner.


Versatility personified - Martin Cranie.



Final Verdict: 


These additions to the squad will bring a lot of different attributes into an already great side that has enough power to swerve a relegation dogfight with ease. Pace, dribbling, passing, vision, power, awareness - just a few of the skills that these players have and with these signings Keith Hill has assembled a quite remarkable squad on a shoestring budget.

Friday, 3 August 2012

Barnsley FC Season Preview


So it’s nearly upon us, the most highly anticipated time of the normal football fan’s calendar year – the start of the season, and to say Barnsley fans will be optimistic could be a bit of an understatement. The high profile signing of Mido along with other Championship standard players has instilled a confidence in the fans that is unfamiliar to some of the younger generation, and this has been reflected in the team’s performances in pre-season. However, that won’t stop the bookies having us down as favourites for relegation.

The current squad on paper looks a lot stronger than last year’s squad, which consisted of lower league players who were full of determination and strived to do well, as opposed to established names that resided in the squad just to pick up a wage. Manager Keith Hill has tried to find a balance of both dedication and reputation in players this summer, and his signings have demonstrated his ability to find the right players that really make a team work efficiently. Kelvin Etuhu is a fantastic example of a player who has had experience in the Championship yet has the commitment to do well and give 100% effort. Despite these exciting signings, Hill has been slandered by some fans for bringing in a host of so called ‘bad boys’ in Etuhu, Jacob Mellis and Mido.

Three players will be vying for the number one spot this season; Luke Steele, Ben Alnwick and Lukas Lidakevicius. All great keepers in their own comfort zones making it a tough call for Hill when deciding who to pick, especially if Ben Alnwick starts the season off well with Steele’s on-going injury keeping him on the sidelines. In my eyes, as soon as Steele is back he has to go into the starting line-up, and I think his player of the season award would agree with me. One of, if not the best shot stopper outside the Premier League and if he keeps up the performances of last season then he’ll soon be in contention for an England call up, which would be thoroughly deserved.



The flying Steele - Luke Steele was player of the year last season.



What is still lacking at the club is a natural leader, and Hill has stressed his desire to bring in a commanding central defender to play this role. The creative Jacob Butterfield and ever-present Stephen Foster have been some of the most recent captains, however they never quite had the vocal presence that, in my opinion, some of the players at the club now have like Stephen Dawson and Jim O’Brien.

The midfield area is looking very strong and the recent acquisition of Portuguese whiz kid Toni Silva has injected even more pace and skill into an already very technical midfield. Jacob Mellis will bring even more technicality to the squad and has the advantage of already knowing some of the players so will fit right in after his loan spell in early 2011. Jim O’Brien will be up there fighting for a place on the wing with Etuhu and Silva and he brings extreme passion to the team which is vital in any successful squad. The strength in depth in central midfield will prove a good attribute and Hill will know this after losing his three most influential central midfielders in January. The rest of the midfield is packed with a mix of both defensive and offensive players in David Perkins, Matt Done, Stephen Dawson, Paul Digby and Jordan Clark, who all have the potential to be Championship quality, if not more.

The final third of the field is where we really need to stock up on, with only one striker in the squad who will be able to cause any real threat to strong defences; Craig Davies. A fantastic debut season has been followed on with some confident pre-season performances; in particular Alfreton away, in which he looked sharper than ever, grabbing two very well taken goals. Aside from the Welshman, the forward department comprises of Chris Dagnall, Danny Rose, and of course the heavily talked about Mido, who has looked off the pace so far. With the right guidance from Keith Hill, all four strikers could flourish throughout the coming season.

Finally onto the messiah, or what most football fans would call a manager; Keith Hill is still a newbie in football management, having only been in the industry six years. His style of play graces the field beautifully at Oakwell and it’s not since the glory days of Danny Wilson have we seen this free flowing football. Could this season see the return of the old saying ‘It’s just like watching Brazil’? Only time will tell. All this said and done, I think a 15th place finish would be a magnificent achievement given the budget Hill’s had to work with. So I leave you all with four words that breathe optimism and enthusiasm... 

COOOOME OOOON YOUUUU REEEEDS!

What a coup - Mido, holding up the Barnsley shirt.

Tuesday, 15 May 2012

Is The Time Right For Jacob?

With Jacob Butterfield's impending departure edging ever closer, Barnsley will be looking to sign up a new midfield magician to replace their influential captain. This short blog post by The View From The Red Zone entails players that have moved on to be unsuccessful and options that the future star may want to consider before leaving Barnsley.

The huge gap that is bound to be left will need to be filled by someone with the flair and tenacity that Butterfield showed on numerous occasions at Oakwell. He further developed his talent and flourished under Keith Hill after being slowly drafted into the first team by ex-manager Mark Robins. He did appear during Simon Davey's reign in charge but never showed the promise back then that he did under Mark Robins and has shown at consistently high levels so far under Keith Hill's brilliant man management skills.


It's an inevitability that the gaping hole Butterfield will leave will take both time and money to fill and Hill's restricted budget means finding that kind of superstar will prove no easy voyage. This asks the question of whether Hill can resurrect another forgotten about player's career as he did with the now Premier League Ricardo Vaz Te. A majority of fans that I have spoken to all echo the same view as I do, in saying that now is not the right time for Butterfield to leave, especially after such a demoralising injury just before the transfer window when it looked certain that the scintillating young talent was going to earn his big money move and achieve his dream of playing in the promised land of the Premier League.


Will he follow in the footsteps of others?

Departing Barnsley now could prove to be an impetuous decision from Butterfield as he only has to take a quick glimpse at the careers of other ex-Barnsley players who thought the grass was greener on the other side.

Firstly we come to Brian Howard. Once dubbed a hero at Oakwell after his Anfield heroics back in 2008, but his hero status was short-lived with the fans and he endured the unfortunate change of hero to villain after joining local rivals Sheffield United. His three year spell at Barnsley was undoubtedly the best of his career in which he won a player of the year award and made it into the team of the year for the 2007-08 season. He was made captain in January 2008 which showed the club's intention to keep him, yet this was to no avail as Howard's time at the club ended in October later that year. Since then he's found himself benched at fellow Championship clubs Reading and Millwall after leaving Sheffield United only a year after signing for them. Howard is similar to Butterfield in the fact that he's an attacking midfielder that can change a game in an instance. He has recently issued a 'come and get me' plea to manager Keith Hill, which I'm sure will have provoked mixed reactions from the Barnsley faithful.



Will the legend be putting on a red shirt again this summer?


Next up is Adam Hammill, his sparkling performances in the first half of the 2010-11 season earned him a £500,000 transfer to Wolverhampton Wanderers where he started off as a regular in the team, but his inconsistency shone just like it did at Barnsley - as Mark Robins said it would - and this saw the tricky winger drop back down into the Championship with high flying Middlesbrough. As it is with most footballers these days, money could have played a massive part in Hammill's decision to move on, and as the young winger found out, moving at the first chance you get isn't always the way forward. This could be food for thought for Butterfield as he ponders over an exciting prospect at such a crucial stage in his career.

Adam Hammill was on course to be Barnsley's player of the season.



Another player who left Oakwell for seemingly bigger things was Maltese target man Daniel Bogdanovic, who followed in Brian Howard's footsteps and jumped on board the sinking ship that was Sheffield United. Loyalty was not a highly ranked priority in his life, as it was after only one-and-a-half seasons with Barnsley that he left to join their South Yorkshire rivals, whom he had 'supported as a boy'. His reasoning for joining the Blades was that he felt they had a better chance at playing in the Premier League than Barnsley and what happened? They were relegated the following season. A gruelling debut year at Bramall Lane saw Bogdanovic net a mere total of five goals from 34 games which was enough to see him shifted on once again from club to club. A surprise move to newly-relegated Blackpool saw him try to rekindle his Championship career, however this never came to fruition and he spent the latter stages of the 2011-12 season on loan at League One strugglers Rochdale and then play-off hopefuls Notts County, notching only three goals across those two spells. Currently without a club after being released in May 2012, Bogdanovic may look to heading back to his native Malta in search of first team football.

Is Bogdanovic's time in England coming to an abrupt end?



The couple that did do well
I've watched Barnsley for about eight years now and in that time I've not seen many players leave and go on to better things, but there are two players that seem to have excelled at their new clubs. Of course, it's that man Ricardo Vaz Te, a nobody in July of last year who looked as though he was going to be left to rot after unsuccessful periods in Greece and Scotland. Keith Hill saw something in him and offered him a trial. After signing a one year deal, Vaz Te went on to score ten league goals in 22 games for Barnsley before moving to West Ham - who are managed by his old boss - where he scored another ten goals including the winner in the play-off final. The other player that has gone on to do well is Jason Shackell, player of the season at Barnsley for the 2010-11 season and all things looked rosy, only for his agent to twist his head at the prospect of doubling his wages. A 12th place finish last season for his new team, Derby, and a considerably better goal difference shows how good a defender he is. The only thing that separates these two doing well and Butterfield doing well is that Butterfield seems destined for the Premier League which will of course prove to be a much harder venture for the young starlet.

My view on proceedings is that it would be foolish for Butterfield to move on at such an early stage in his career, however if he doesn't want to be here then he should go as this would benefit the team morale and his bank account, but would tarnish his reputation with some Barnsley fans as well as show total disrespect towards the club and its fans. Granted we'd all take a doubled salary if it was offered, but for the sake of his career I believe the best option would be at least an extra year at Oakwell. Only time will tell...

Sunday, 29 April 2012

End Of Season Review

With a 7th successive season in the NPower Championship being secured last week - and rather fortuitously due to Portsmouth's points deduction - The View From The Red Zone looks back on what has proved to be yet another anti-climax of a season for Barnsley, or has it?

Pre-season saw Barnsley appoint Keith Hill and David Flitcroft, otherwise known as Hillcroft. They brought something different to the table that past managers hadn't - a mesmerising brand of neat passing football that had gained them recognition from a host of Championship clubs. There was no hesitancy in changing the squad around as eight new faces came in and nine players departed. The most notable signings were undoubtedly Craig Davies, whose 25 goals last season earned him a place in League Two's PFA team of the year, and Ricardo Vaz Te, who had so far had unsuccessful spells in England, Greece and Scotland. The notable, yet unsurprising outgoings were 2009-10 player of the year Hugo Colace, and 2010-2011 player of the year Jason Shackell. Barnsley won every pre-season game, including a comfortable 2-0 win over neighbours Sheffield Wednesday and a 5-0 annihilation of Scunthorpe.


Apart from Keith Hill, no manager was willing to take a gamble on the Portuguese 25 year old.


Cast your minds back to August. A warm summer day in Nottingham and Barnsley were again on their travels for the first game of the season. A huge level of anticipation could be felt throughout the club and its fans for the coming season after the appointment of Keith Hill, along with assistant David Flitcroft. The match kicked off, the air filled with optimism from the 2,000 travelling fans who were in full voice from start to finish. A valiant performance from a Barnsley side that were expected to be heavily beaten by promotion hopefuls Nottingham Forest resulted in a 0-0 draw and a share of the spoils.

The following couple of games for Barnsley prompted a small section of the fans to call for Hill's head after a cup exit at the hands of League Two Morecambe and two consecutive league defeats at home to Southampton and Middlesbrough. These shouts for Hill to be sacked seemed to make something click as The Reds went on to record a 2-1 victory away at eventual champions Reading and finished off the first month of the campaign at Millwall with a mirrored result of Forest away. Manchester United youngster Daniel Drinkwater was brought in on a three month loan deal and had an instant connection with central midfield maestro Jacob Butterfield.

September saw The Tykes go unbeaten, yet winless all the way through the month. Four 1-1 draws against Leicester, Watford, Birmingham and Derby respectively saw this little unbeaten run extended to six games. Jacob Butterfield started to show his true quality chipping in with three goals in four games whilst veteran striker Andy Gray netted the only other goal of the month.

October proved to be a better month points-wise as Barnsley picked up six points from a possible fifteen. They started the month in fine form with a 2-0 victory over lowly Coventry which extended the unbeaten sequence to seven - the longest run without a loss since the 8 games in November and December of 2009. Unfortunately this was followed by a 2-0 defeat at Portsmouth in Barnsley's first televised game of the season. This also ended the Oakwell outfit's unbeaten away record. Barnsley showed great resilience to bounce back in to the next game at home to Burnley in which they recorded at 2-0 win with Ricardo Vaz Te getting off the mark. Continuing in typical Barnsley fashion, they succumbed to defeat in the next game away at Cardiff City. The only positive to be taken from the game was the Jimmy McNulty strike which happened to be the 4,000th league goal scored by Barnsley.

The October fixtures came to a close at Oakwell with the visit of bottom of the league Bristol City. Exciting summer signing Craig Davies showed his predator instincts to react quickest to a slot home the equalizer before Nicky Maynard kept up his rich vein of form against Barnsley to fire home a 93rd minute winner in front of the Bristol faithful - his 5th in his last four outings against The Reds.

Just like October, November started just as well with Luke Steele saving a penalty in a 2-1 victory over Hull in the first game of the month. Barnsley kept up their consistent inconsistency by going on to suffer a 2-0 defeat at Brighton on Bonfire Weekend. The international break came at just the right time for South Yorkshire's number one club as they bounced back from defeat on the South Coast to win the first Yorkshire derby of the season, against Doncaster Rovers at Oakwell - Craig Davies getting his 2nd and 3rd goals of the season. Was this the start of a run of sensational results for The Reds? The final weekend of November saw Barnsley claim Leeds United's scalp on Leeds' own turf in a game that Barnsley fans will remember for a long time to come.

London Road was the first destination of December and Barnsley knew it would be tough to get a result at free scoring Peterborough, despite having a brilliant record against the Cambridgeshire club. The match fought out provided goals galore in a 4-3 success for Barnsley. A very high thrill factor indeed as Peterborough scored three goals in six minutes to make up a 3-0 deficit, only for Craig Davies to smash home a goal of the season contender with 12 minutes remaining to steal the points. Swiftly following that encounter came a 2-1 win at home to Crystal Palace - Ricardo Vaz Te scoring inside 7 seconds. This run of four wins on the bounce sparked talks of a play-off place between Barnsley supporters, which unfortunately never came to fruition. Another televised match, against Ipswich at Oakwell saw Barnsley lead 2-0 at half time, only to be humiliated as Ipswich ran riot in the 2nd half scoring five times. Defeats to West Ham and Blackpool came and the boo-boys were again in full voice. Barnsley rounded off 2011 with a scintillating 4-1 hammering of Leeds United.



The four scorers against Peterborough. From left to right: Vaz Te, Davies, Butterfield, O'Brien.



The half-way point of the season came and Barnsley were twelve points above safety sitting comfortably in 13th place, in contrast to last season when the club sat in 16th position hovering only six points above the dreaded drop zone. A slight improvement yes, but not all the fans were on Keith Hill's side yet and that wasn't about to change. Craig Davies and Ricardo Vaz Te had showed the understanding they had of each other as they contributed with 19 of the 35 goals that Barnsley had scored so far. An injury sustained against Leeds meant that influential captain Jacob Butterfield would miss the remainder of the season.

2012 started off in awful fashion. Rumours circulated that hat-trick hero Ricardo Vaz Te had rejected a new contract offer, Barnsley lost 2-0 to local rivals Doncaster Rovers, and more rumours circulated about vile chants from Barnsley 'fans' towards Billy Sharp about his late son, Luey. I use the term 'fans' very loosely. The 3rd round of the FA Cup was the next test against another free-flowing passing team in Swansea. Barnsley were once again valiant, but bowed out with a 4-2 loss. Marvellous performances against Leicester and Derby sandwiched a lacklustre performance against Millwall. Keith Hill brought in several lower league players, much to the disapproval of many Barnsley fans. This was a poignant reminder of the club's financial difficulties.

February brought misery to most Barnsley fans. Four defeats and only one win lead to a slump down the table. The only points came against administration bound Portsmouth. The result was identical to the reverse fixture, with the home side taking the points again. Defender Scott Golbourne opened his account on his debut away at Watford after being signed in January from Exeter City.

March was another very bad month for Barnsley, as they picked up a mere four points from seven games. They started with the visit of Nottingham Forest and recovered from a goal down to rescue a point and secure their first draw in 25 outings. Up next was a trip to the Riverside Stadium to face high flying Middlesbrough, but to no avail. The subsequent game echoed the result of the Middlesbrough match as Barnsley went down 2-0 at Southampton's peril. Keith Hill tried to shake it up by bringing in four loanees; Frank Nouble, Lee Collins, David Button and Kallum Higginbotham. It appeared that the 42 year old was running out of ideas and this shone through with an embarrassing 4-0 home defeat to Reading. A single goal loss away at Crystal Palace was the next step in the chapter. What followed though was an astute performance at home to Peterborough after going a man down to win 1-0, in which Stephen Dawson put in a masterful shift. His effort and commitment to get the job done in a professional and highly effective manner got people talking about possible captaincy and a future Barnsley legend. The Reds ended March going down 1-0 at Portman Road to a rejuvenated Ipswich side.

The final month of the season was in no way better than the past few months and Barnsley failed to register a maximum in any game. This was also the worst points total for an individual month since August 2009 - the month of Simon Davey's sacking. The team started off with their 3rd televised game of the season at home to West Ham United and someone somewhere struck a self-destruct button as Barnsley found themselves 3-0 down after only 35 minutes. Old boy Ricardo Vaz Te capped West Ham's scoring with an easy finish and a muted celebration to go with it. Barnsley's run in looked seemingly difficult and it looked as though they could be dragged into the relegation mix. After the West Ham debacle, a changed Barnsley team travelled to play-off certainties Blackpool a grabbed a fantastic point, courtesy of a fluke goal from David Perkins. Three games followed, no points gained and only one goal scored.



Highlights of the 4-0 thumping at the hands of West Ham United.


 

Barnsley faced Brighton on the final day and both teams served up a pretty dour game. A few of the youngsters started the game and showed signs of promise - Jordan Clark, in particular. Academy graduate John Stones missed a gilt-edged chance to win the game for the home team in the dying seconds.

On the whole it's been a successful, yet unsuccessful season in ways. Club general manager Don Rowing stated that at the beginning of the season Keith Hill's aims were to keep the club in the league and to break even. The first aim was achieved a couple of weeks back against Hull due to Coventry's defeat to Millwall. However, it is only by default that the club has stayed in the division. Had it not been for Portsmouth's inability to only spend what they could afford then they would not have been deducted the ten points which took us above them. Don Rowing has come out to say the second aim of breaking even is on course to be achieved.

Looking back at where the club has finished since its promotion back to English football's second division, this has been the 2nd most successful season with the club finishing in 21st place and eight points above the relegation zone. Compare that to the season of 2007-08, where we finished the nearest to the play-offs we've been, yet only stayed up by three points.

Squad changes aplenty have already taken place with six players being released when their respective contracts end in June. These are; David Preece, Alistair Taylor, Jay McEveley, Nathan Doyle, David Cotterill and Andy Gray. Keith Hill has already stated his intentions to sign four or five Championship standard players on permanent deals, as well as three trialists and in addition to these, a couple of loan players.












Andy Gray (above), and Nathan Doyle (below) have both been great servants to the club.


 

Tuesday, 20 March 2012

Second Half Syndrome

It's the same old story season after season for Barnsley. A new manager, new signings, and still no change. When Keith Hill took charge of Barnsley, people were expecting drastic changes for the forthcoming season, yet in some fans' eyes, it's proved to be another big expectation, and another big disappointment. In my opinion he's done a fantastic job. The budget he was limited to was that of a mid-table League One club and once again he's defied the odds by taking the Oakwell club to 18th in the table with them still a clear nine points above the dreaded relegation zone. Since the turn of the year, Barnsley have slipped down the table, winning only three of their games since the 4-1 demolition of Leeds United on the last day of 2011. Our season very much reflects most of our games - fantastic first half and a dire second half. Ipswich at home is a defining example of this. What I want to know though, is what causes this second half of the season slump?

The players

Could the players be the cause of the dip in form after the half-way point in the season? Several players come and go in each transfer window of every season for Barnsley and yet the outcome is always the same. A good run of form always comes about towards the end of the calendar year, and this creates a good buzz and atmosphere at the club. However, after the turn of the year when we're seemingly safe, the players appear to lack effort, look disinterested and just don't have the willingness to see out the season. The fans get restless and boo the team and this then puts a lot of pressure on the players to perform better to stop them from getting dragged into the relegation fodder, as is usually the case. As well as a lack of effort, the vast amount of changes that occur at Oakwell result in players never really getting the chance to bond with others and develop a good team spirit and high morale in the camp. Barnsley are often cited by many as a selling club and a stepping stone for players to get themselves in the shop window, and with key players leaving in January, this has once again seemed to be the case with Ricardo Vaz Te and Daniel Drinkwater moving on. The timing of when the players left didn't help the club, with Vaz Te leaving with only a few hours left of the transfer window.


The departure of Vaz Te (left) and Drinkwater haven't helped Barnsley's cause.




The manager


Keith Hill has surpassed the club's expectations of keeping them in the league in his first year at the helm, but the fans are becoming increasingly tired of his excuses for the poor run of form the team are currently on. Is he the reason we're doing so badly in this second half of the season? Fans moan that his ideas are draining and that he has no reply to the way teams play against us. They believe he is clutching at straws by experimenting with players in new positions, this was shown through playing Jay McEveley at centre back and Nathan Doyle at right back. Even the @Not_Keith_Hill account on Twitter suggested that he may play David Preece on the left wing as his next masterstroke. The majority of supporters are still, like me, 100% behind Hill and his backroom staff and believe he is the man to take us to the Premier League one day. The recent criticism he has come under though is undeserved. He says that the loss of our midfield has played a big part in the drop of form. Before Christmas, the team went on a four game winning streak with a midfield consisting of Jim O'Brien, David Perkins, Jacob Butterfield, Daniel Drinkwater and Ricardo Vaz Te, of whom the latter two have now left the club - the other three are currently injured and it looks highly unlikely that the Butterfield will sign a new contract extension, leaving Hill to ponder upon trying to rebuild a midfield with the same flair and tenacity.

Butterfield was the heart of the team.




The fans

Are the fans the main impact on Barnsley's slump into the second half of the season? The fans are the only factor of the club that stays constant throughout. Players come and go, managers come and go, but the fans stay. The player changes in the transfer window always mean that the squad will be weaker afterwards, as is the case with this season, yet fans still expect the team to be performing at the levels they were when they had their most influential players. It's inevitable that the team will take a dip in form going into the final stretch of the season without their key players carrying them on and it's unfortunate that the minority of fans fail to realise Hill is doing the best he can with what resources he has to work with. Although they may not know it, the booing that comes from certain sections of the Oakwell crowd will affect the players' confidence going into the next match. Direct criticism on Twitter is also another contributing factor towards knocking a player's confidence. This can then have a domino effect and pass on to the whole squad. In my opinion the small section of mindless fans that boo and moan are the main influence on our bad form. The sooner they become optimistic instead of pessimistic, the sooner I believe results will come. The positivity was gleaming around Oakwell in the home game vs Peterborough United and that spurred the team onto a vital victory. That hardwork and grit combined was further helped by the fans togetherness and ability to create a fantastic atmosphere.


Ironically, the Oakwell 'faithful' seem to lose faith.